1987: Baltimore Thunder

1988: New York Saints

1989: Philadelphia Wings

1990: Philadelphia Wings

1991: Detroit Turbos

1992: Buffalo Bandits

1993: Buffalo Bandits

1994: Philadelphia Wings

1995: Philadelphia Wings

1996: Buffalo Bandits

1997: Rochester Knighthawks

1998: Philadelphia Wings

 1999: Toronto Rock

2000: Toronto Rock

2001: Philadelphia Wings